There's More Than One Right Marketing Answer

By 4 min read
There's More Than One Right Marketing Answer

There is rarely one right marketing plan for a small business. Usually there are several good options, and the best one depends on your goals, your customers, your budget and how much time you have. The smart move is to compare a few realistic paths, pick the one that fits best now and adjust as results come in.

Our partner John Graham Seeliger put it plainly: "Right and wrong may not be the only choice. There's often more than one right answer."

That's freeing if you've been stuck hunting for the perfect plan. It's also a warning about anyone who sells a single package as the answer for every business.

Why isn't there one right marketing plan?

Because no two businesses start from the same place. A new bakery in Queen Creek and a long-established accounting firm in Tempe both need customers. They don't need the same marketing.

The right mix depends on things only you know:

  • Who your best customers are and how they decide to buy
  • How much you can spend, and how fast you need results
  • What you're good at and what you'd rather hand off
  • What's already working that you shouldn't touch
  • How much new work you can actually handle

That's why we don't sell one-size-fits-all programs. A plan that's perfect for one business can be a waste of money for the next.

It's also why copying a competitor rarely works. You see their ads and their posts. You don't see their budget, their margins or whether any of it is paying off. What looks like a winning plan from the outside may be one they're quietly regretting.

What makes a marketing option right for your business?

Start with the basics. The U.S. Small Business Administration's guide to marketing and sales puts it simply: know your customers and plan how to reach them. It also notes that a marketing plan can persuade consumers to buy.

Notice what it doesn't say. It doesn't name one channel or one tactic. Any option that reaches your real customers, fits your budget and moves them to buy can be a right answer.

So an option is "right" when it does three things:

  1. Serves a clear goal. More calls, bigger jobs, repeat customers. If you can't name the goal yet, read start with the goal, not the tactic.
  2. Reaches the people who actually buy. Not everyone. Your people.
  3. Fits your resources. Money, time and energy. A plan you can't sustain isn't a plan.

How do you compare several good marketing options?

Once you have two or three options that pass that test, compare them side by side. Keep it simple. A sheet of paper works fine.

For each option, write down:

  • Cost to start. What it takes to get going.
  • Ongoing cost. Monthly money and hours.
  • Time to results. Days, weeks or months.
  • Fit with your strengths. Do you enjoy it, or will it get ignored by week three?
  • How easy it is to test. Can you try it small before you commit?
  • How easy it is to stop. Are you locked into a contract?

The option that wins isn't always the cheapest or the fastest. It's the one with the best balance for where your business is right now.

What does choosing between good options look like in real life?

Say you run a handyman business in Mesa and you want more jobs this fall. Three options all make sense:

  • Google Ads for searches like "handyman near me." Fast results, ongoing cost, easy to test small.
  • Google Business Profile and reviews. Low cost, slower to build, keeps working for years.
  • Referral partners like real estate agents and property managers. Low cost, relies on relationships, can bring bigger jobs.

None of these is wrong. If you need jobs next month, ads may come first. If cash is tight but you have time, the profile and referrals may come first. Many businesses end up doing two of the three, in an order that makes sense for them.

The point is to choose on purpose instead of copying what a competitor did or what a salesperson pushed. Any of the three can be the right answer. The wrong answer is picking none of them, or trying all of them at once with no plan to tell which one is working.

How do you know when to switch paths?

Treat your choice as a test, not a vow. Set a check-in date and a few simple measures before you start. When that date comes, look honestly at the results. Decide ahead of time what "working" means, so you're judging the numbers and not your mood that week.

If it's working, keep it and consider expanding it. If it's slipping, fix it. If it's clearly failing, shut it down fast and try the next option on your list. That's the advantage of having more than one right answer: you always have a backup. For more on treating campaigns this way, see you succeed or you learn.

The bottom line

Stop looking for the one perfect marketing plan. It doesn't exist. Look for a few good options that fit your goals, your customers and your budget, then pick one and start.

Choosing well gets easier with a clear goal and an outside view. That's what our Strategy Session is for: finding the most efficient, profitable direction for your business, not a one-size-fits-all package. Or if you'd like to talk it through first, let's talk strategies.

Frequently asked questions

Is there one best marketing plan for a small business?

No. The best plan depends on your goals, your customers, your budget and your time, so two businesses in the same industry can have different right answers. The goal is to pick a good option that fits your situation now and adjust based on results.

How do I choose between marketing options like ads, social media and referrals?

Compare each option on startup cost, ongoing cost, time to results, fit with your strengths and how easy it is to test and stop. The best choice is the one that balances those factors for where your business is today, not simply the cheapest or fastest.

What should a Mesa small business focus on first in its marketing?

Start with a clear goal and an honest look at who your best customers are and how they find businesses like yours. From there, choose one or two options that reach those customers within your budget, such as Google Ads, a strong Google Business Profile or referral partners.

What does the Best Shot Marketing Strategy Session include?

The Strategy Session is a $495 deep dive into your goals, the message that resonates with your customers and the most efficient, profitable direction for your marketing. It helps you choose between good options with confidence instead of guessing.

How long should I try a marketing option before switching?

Set a check-in date before you start and decide in advance which results you will look at. If it's working, keep it, if it's slipping, fix it, and if it's clearly failing, stop and move to your next option.

Keep reading

Start with strategy. We will help you build from there.

Tell us where you want your business to go. We listen, then build a customized program just for you.

Let’s talk strategies